This Asteroid Pulverization System May Be Earth's Only Chance

This Asteroid Pulverization System May Be Earth's Only Chance

Planetary defence is top of mind for some scientists and engineers, such as Professor Philip Lubin from the University of California Santa Barbara.
Rubin is working on a project called PI-Terminal Defense for Humanity. The PI stands for Pulverize It, and Lubin thinks pulverizing an asteroid into tiny pieces is our best defence on short notice.

Rubin presented his PI Planetary Defense idea at the 2021 Planetary Defence Conference. In NASA's Innovative Advanced Concepts (NIAC) program, his idea is now a Phase One winner. NASA's Innovation and Advanced Concepts Center promotes visionary ideas that can transform future missions.
Lubin's PI Planetary Defense idea fits NASA's Planetary Defence Coordination Office (PDCO).

Asteroids are a real threat. Our civilization would die from an asteroid like the one that wiped out the dinosaurs. Tunguska and the Chelyabinsk meteor are more minor threats, but can we count on luck to avoid devastating impacts? Probably not.
"So far, humanity has been spared large-scale catastrophe as was visited upon our previous tenants, but counting upon being 'lucky' is a poor strategy in the longer term," Philip Lubin said in 2021.

NASA has been finding and cataloguing asteroids that threaten the Earth. But that's only the beginning. We need to find ways to protect it.

Asteroid impact mitigation is mostly about long lead times. When we know months or years in advance when an asteroid will impact Earth, we can send out a kinetic impactor to redirect it. An asteroid can be redirected by a small kinetic impactor if we have enough lead time.

What if we're short on time? And what if we're too late? How about if we launch a kinetic impactor and it misses? Lubin's PI idea could come in handy here.


The Pulverize It scenario. (Lubin/Experimental Cosmology Group, UCSB)


The main idea of PI is to pulverize an asteroid into smaller debris which would then burn up in Earth's atmosphere.

In an article for NIAC from February 18th, 2022, Lubin wrote:

"In short intercept scenarios, the asteroid fragments of maximum ~10-meter [about 33 ft] diameter allow the Earth's atmosphere to act as a 'beam dump' where the fragments either burn up in the atmosphere or air burst, with the primary channel of energy going into spatially and temporally de-correlated shock waves."

PI's idea is to design an impactor that's not only kinetic but explosive. The impacting device would be fitted with penetrating rods to pierce the asteroid. Explosives would fill some rods, and the resulting explosion would pulverize the bolide into smaller chunks, hopefully 15 m or less in diameter.

The pieces would form a cloud of debris. Depending on the size of the bolide, the size of the device, and the distance from Earth when detonated, some of the debris might strike Earth. But much of it would be destroyed through friction with the Earth's atmosphere.

"The effectiveness of the approach depends on the time to intercept and size of the asteroid, but allows for effective defense against asteroids in the multi-hundred-meter diameter class and could virtually eliminate the threat of mass destruction caused by these threats," Lubin explains.

According to Lubin, the PI System could be in orbit around Earth or even housed on a lunar base.

"Compared to other threat reduction scenarios, this approach represents an extremely cost-effective, testable, and deployable approach with a logical roadmap of development and testing. Pre-deployment of the system into orbit or a lunar base allows for rapid response on the order of less than a day if needed," Lubin said.

"The great advantage of this approach is that it allows for terminal defense in the event of short warning times and target distance mitigation where orbital deflection is not feasible," said Lubin. "Even intercepts as close as the Moon with intercept times of a few hours prior to impact are viable."

The Moon has a couple of inherent advantages. For one thing, it has no atmosphere, so as a base for observing the asteroid environment near Earth, it would allow "long-range optical/NIR LIDAR detection" of incoming asteroids. The Moon also has a lower escape velocity than Earth, making launches easier and less expensive.


Fragment clouds from interceptions of small (top) and large (bottom) asteroids. (Lubin 2021)

Launching a large explosive impactor from Earth is becoming more feasible over time, too. Heavy launch vehicles like SpaceX's Falcon Heavy, NASA's Space Launch System, and others are heralding a new age of powerful rocket technology.

Lubin says that the PI system only needs a five-hour prior to impact window to destroy an asteroid the size of the object in the Tunguska Event.

That object was likely about 50 meters in diameter and exploded with a force of about 10 Megatons. It knocked over millions of trees in a remote part of Siberia. If an object that size were to explode over one of our cities, it would be devastating.

The Chelyabinsk meteor blew the windows out of buildings and caused injuries, and it was only about 20 meters in diameter.

The system could also work when it comes to massive asteroids like Apophis. Apophis will pass near Earth in 2029, but it won't impact Earth. However, if it passes through what's called a "gravitational keyhole" during its 2029 flyby, it could be nudged enough that it could strike Earth on the subsequent flyby.

Apophis is about 370 meters in diameter, and its yield is about four gigatons. Lubin said that his PI system could successfully destroy Apophis-sized asteroids with a 10-day prior to impact intercept.

It'll be interesting to see how much further Lubin develops his Pulverize It asteroid defense idea. NASA launched its Double Asteroid Redirection Test mission in November 2021. DART is headed for the double asteroid system of Didymos and its smaller companion, Dimorphos, which orbits Didymos.

Dimorphos isn't on a trajectory toward Earth. DART is purely a test mission, and impacting Dimorphos will lead to a slight change in the trajectory of the double asteroid system. NASA will monitor the system after the impact to see if the mission was successful.

But there's no reason we can't develop multiple asteroid mitigation systems in parallel. That might be the most prudent way forward.

As we get better and better at finding all of the asteroids that threaten Earth, we'll be more prepared for intercepting asteroids with advanced lead times. But no system is foolproof.

It'd be wise for humanity to develop another system that could launch rapidly and be employed on short notice. Then we can look up at the sky and relax.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.

Supporter Merchandise

1 of 4